The Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Diets

Healthy Dog Food
October 3, 2023
The word Kibbies in blue font
This article is brought to you by Kibbies - the dog food made with whole, fresh ingredients.
Learn More at
Finger pointing towards text about kibbies
In This Article:

The Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Diets: Are They Right for Your Pet?

The debate over homemade dog food versus commercial dog food options has gained traction over the past few years, and in this article, we’ll explore this emerging trend. Advocates of homemade dog diets appreciate the control this option affords in selecting high-quality ingredients, avoiding fillers, and tailoring meals to their individual pet’s needs. However, in addition to the positive outcomes, we will also explore the potential pitfalls associated with this canine diet option. Read on to learn about the pros and cons of homemade dog food options to determine whether it’s the right decision for your pet.

Pros of Homemade Dog Food

When it comes to feeding our beloved canine companions, one option that has gained popularity in recent years is homemade dog food. This option offers pet owners the opportunity to have complete control over what goes into their dog’s meals, which potentially provides a healthier and more tailored diet.

One of the key advantages of adopting a homemade dog diet plan is the control over the ingredients, as mentioned above. By preparing meals from scratch, pet owners can carefully select high-quality ingredients and work to ensure that their dogs are not consuming any unnecessary fillers, artificial additives, or potentially harmful substances. This control over dog food ingredients can be particularly beneficial for dogs that have specific dietary needs or live with certain health conditions. Homemade food options allow dog owners to avoid ingredients that may trigger adverse reactions in their pets. (6)

Additionally, homemade dog food provides owners with the flexibility to customize meals according to the unique needs of each individual dog. Just like humans, dogs have different nutritional needs that are based on factors such as age, breed, size, and activity level. With homemade dog food, owners have the ability to tailor the meals to their dog’s specific needs, which helps ensure that they receive the right balance of proteins, carbohydrates, fats, and essential nutrients.

A homemade dog diet also has the potential to provide dogs with greater nutritional value compared to some commercial dog food options. While commercial dog food often goes through extensive processing, which may result in the loss of some nutrients, homemade meals can retain more of their natural nutritional content. This can be especially beneficial for dogs who have health conditions or older dogs who may require higher levels of certain nutrients to support their overall well-being. (2)

Finally, preparing homemade dog food can help foster a stronger bond between owners and their canine companions. The act of cooking for your dog has the potential to become a shared experience, which enhances the human/canine relationship and creates a sense of satisfaction in providing personalized, loving care for a cherished member of the family.

Cons of Homemade Dog Food

While the idea of preparing homemade meals for our canine companions may sound appealing at first, there are potential drawbacks to this option that need to be considered before pet owners decide on homemade dog diets.

One of the main considerations to keep in mind when it comes to homemade dog food is the time and effort required in meal planning and preparation. Unlike commercial dog food, which can be conveniently purchased and served, homemade dog food involves sourcing ingredients, preparing and cooking them, and ensuring that each meal is nutritionally balanced. This can be a time-consuming endeavor, especially for busy pet owners who have limited time available for meal preparation. (4)

Another challenge related to homemade dog food is the need for expertise in canine nutrition. It is essential to understand the specific nutritional requirements of dogs and ensure that the homemade meals you create meet those needs. Without proper knowledge and research, there is a risk of unintentional nutritional imbalances that could negatively impact your dog’s health. For example, an inadequate intake of certain vitamins and minerals can lead to deficiencies, while an excess can also have detrimental effects.

There is a significant risk when it comes to nutritional imbalances when choosing a homemade dog diet. Unlike most commercial brands that are formulated to meet the nutritional standards set by regulatory bodies, homemade dog food options rely on the owner’s understanding of canine nutrition. Without careful planning and consideration, it’s possible to create an unbalanced diet that lacks certain essential nutrients. This is why consulting with a veterinarian or canine nutritionist is highly recommended before switching to a homemade dog diet. (3)

Finally, pet owners should also be aware of the financial considerations associated with homemade dog food. While the cost of commercial dog food is often straightforward, homemade meals may involve higher expenses due to the quality of the ingredients selected. Dog owners need to assess their budget before making a choice in order to ensure that they can sustain the financial commitment required for preparing nutritious homemade meals for their canine companions.

Considerations Before Switching to Homemade Dog Food

Before deciding to switch over to homemade dog food, there are several important considerations that pet owners need to keep in mind.

Firstly, before taking any steps toward implementing a homemade dog food regimen, it’s crucial to consult with a veterinarian. A veterinarian can provide valuable guidance and help assess whether homemade dog food is suitable for a specific dog based on their current health condition, age, and individual dietary needs. They can also provide owners with recommendations on the specific nutrients that should be included in homemade dog food meals to help create a well-balanced diet. (5)

Secondly, pet owners need to assess their own ability to commit to the time and work that goes into meal planning and preparation. Adhering to a homemade dog diet plan can be demanding, and it is essential to evaluate whether there is enough time available in daily routines to dedicate to the task at hand. What’s more, pet owners also need to consider the availability and affordability of high-quality ingredients needed to create balanced and nutritious meals for their dogs. (8)

It’s also important to recognize that the transition to homemade dog food may not be suitable for all dogs. Some dogs may have specific dietary needs that are better met through the provision of specialized commercial diets. Considering a dog’s individual requirements and overall health is crucial when it comes to making the most informed decision.

Lastly, pet owners need to be aware of the potential challenges that may arise during the transition period. Dogs may initially be resistant to trying new foods and adjusting portion sizes may be necessary to help a dog maintain a healthy weight. Gradual introduction and monitoring under the guidance of a veterinarian can help ease the transition and ensure the dog’s nutritional needs are met and maintained.

Guidelines for Preparing Homemade Dog Food

If after careful consideration, a dog owner decides to switch to homemade dog food, there are some essential guidelines they should follow in order to ensure that the meals they prepare are nutritionally balanced and beneficial for the dog’s health.

Firstly, it is crucial to use a balanced recipe that’s specifically designed for homemade dog food. These recipes take into account the nutritional needs of dogs and provide guidance on the appropriate proportions of protein, carbohydrates, fats, and essential nutrients to include. Following a balanced recipe can help minimize the risk of nutritional imbalances and make sure that a dog’s dietary requirements are met. (1)

It’s important to include essential nutrients in homemade dog food options. Dogs require a wide range of vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients for optimal health. Some nutrients, such as calcium, omega-3 fatty acids, and certain vitamins, may require additional supplementation to ensure the accuracy of each serving. Speak with a veterinarian or canine nutritionist to help identify the supplements you need and how to properly administer them. (7)

Further, introducing variety into a dog’s diet by rotating protein sources and incorporating different vegetables and grains can enhance the nutritional profile of homemade meals. This variety helps prevent nutrient deficiencies and adds interest to the dog’s diet.

Lastly, portioning and storing recommendations should be followed in order to maintain the freshness and safety of homemade dog diets. Proper portioning helps prevent overfeeding or underfeeding and ensures that dogs receive the right amount of food at each meal. Additionally, storing meals in suitable containers and following appropriate food safety practices can help prevent spoilage and the growth of harmful bacteria.

Homemade dog food can be a beneficial option for pet owners who are willing to put in the time and effort to provide their furry friends with a carefully tailored diet. The control over ingredients and the potential for higher nutritional value are definite advantages. However, it is essential to consider the potential challenges, such as the need for expertise in canine nutrition and the risk of nutritional imbalance. Consulting with a veterinarian, assessing the dog's individual dietary requirements, and evaluating available time and resources are crucial steps before making the switch. By following balanced recipes, including essential nutrients, and adhering to portioning and storage guidelines, pet owners can ensure that their homemade dog food provides optimal nutrition and contributes to their dog's overall health and well-being.


  1. Ardente, A., DVM PhD. (2022c, August 16). Homemade dog food: Is it healthy to cook for your dog?
  1. Child, D., & Child, D. (2023d, January 24). Science Backed Benefits of Home Cooking for your Dog. Dog Child.,dry%20kibble%20day%20after%20day
  1. Nscott. (2021, March 17). Homemade Dog Food & Treats - Pros and Cons | Richell USA Inc. | blog. Richell USA Inc.
  1. Downs, A. (2022b, April 22). 20 Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Food Recipes (And Some Myths). Top Dog Tips.
  1. Homemade Food For Dogs - Yay Or Nay? (n.d.).
  1. Sysop. (2020, May 20). Cooking for your Pet. Holiday Barn Pet Resorts.
  1. How to Make Homemade Dog Food. (2012, July 9).
  1. What You Need to Know About Homemade Dog Food | The Dog Nest. (n.d.).

Give your pup the love they deserve with Kibbies' natural dog food.

Shop Kibbies